PHILIP ESTRADA
  • Projects
    • dear Plastic
    • Something New
    • Nothing New
    • Shift
    • Ritual
    • Colors and Shapes
    • Tensegrity
    • Lakeview Cut
    • Second Nature
    • It Gets Funkier
    • Making Space
    • Rotational Volumes
    • Changed By Chairs
    • Gearboxes
    • Pendulums
    • Microscopic Images
    • Inspraytion
    • 60 Word Short Stories
    • PBL Illustrations
    • Foundations Podcast
    • Inclusive Strategies Podcast
  • Helpful Links
    • Engagement Grading
    • Critique Questions
    • Lasercutting
    • Drawing Models
    • Honors
    • Zine Printing
  • Blog
  • About

OBSERVATION

Notes and reflections from teaching through projects

Why Not Learn As Much As Possible?

11/6/2024

0 Comments

 
Every year, seniors at our school are required to plan and prepare an exit interview. There are required slides and topics, and they must bring parents and trusted adults. Failure to meet these requirements, we tell them, will result in being banned from graduation ceremonies. While positive in spirit, this structure is failing to provide accurate assessment of our students and our effectiveness as educators. By making exit interviews voluntary and removing excessive structure, we would get a more authentic and valuable assessment of both student capabilities and our schools’ effectiveness.
​

In the professional world, exit interviews are very different. When employees leave a role, they're invited—not required—to share their experiences. Their choice to participate and their level of engagement reveals the true nature of their relationship with the institution. Do they reject the invitation? Do they show up with prepared material? This valuable information emerges only because participation is voluntary. In our school, we lose this insight by coercing students into participating through graduation requirements.

Our excessive scaffolding—required slides, artifacts, topics, and family participation—further limits our view of students' true capabilities. While scaffolds have their place, they're inappropriate in evaluation because they mask actual abilities and values. When we dictate exactly what and how students must present, all that we really learn is how well they follow directions! 

I propose eliminating both the graduation requirement and all but the essential structure of exit interviews. We would provide only a date and time, making it clear that the format and content are entirely up to the students. This approach transforms the interview from an obligation into an opportunity—a chance for students to be celebrated and demonstrate their learning in ways meaningful to them. By making participation voluntary, we would gain valuable insights into how students value us and our school. By letting them choose the content, we could learn what they found most important in their educational journey.

The stakes are real because every year we have only one chance to hear from our graduating class about their experiences—to truly understand what it’s like to be a student at our school. By forcing participation and dictating content we limit what we can learn about our students. By trusting our students to show us what matters to them, we'll not only learn more about their capabilities but also gain insights about ours. Why wouldn’t we learn as much as we can?
0 Comments

    Author

    Philip Estrada is a teacher at High Tech High Media Arts in San Diego California. He teaches by having kids build things in a woodshop.

    Archives

    November 2024
    October 2024
    September 2024
    May 2022
    November 2020
    August 2020
    December 2019
    September 2019
    June 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017

    Categories

    All
    Assessment
    Doing PBL
    Perspectives
    Planning PBL
    Things To Try

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly
  • Projects
    • dear Plastic
    • Something New
    • Nothing New
    • Shift
    • Ritual
    • Colors and Shapes
    • Tensegrity
    • Lakeview Cut
    • Second Nature
    • It Gets Funkier
    • Making Space
    • Rotational Volumes
    • Changed By Chairs
    • Gearboxes
    • Pendulums
    • Microscopic Images
    • Inspraytion
    • 60 Word Short Stories
    • PBL Illustrations
    • Foundations Podcast
    • Inclusive Strategies Podcast
  • Helpful Links
    • Engagement Grading
    • Critique Questions
    • Lasercutting
    • Drawing Models
    • Honors
    • Zine Printing
  • Blog
  • About