PHILIP ESTRADA
  • Projects
    • Shift
    • Ritual
    • Colors and Shapes
    • Tensegrity
    • Lakeview Cut
    • Second Nature
    • It Gets Funkier
    • Making Space
    • Rotational Volumes
    • Changed By Chairs
    • Gearboxes
    • Pendulums
    • Microscopic Images
    • Inspraytion
    • 60 Word Short Stories
    • PBL Illustrations
    • Foundations Podcast
    • Inclusive Strategies Podcast
  • Helpful Links
    • Critique Questions
    • Lasercutting
    • Drawing Models
    • Honors
  • Blog
  • About

Sample Questions for Useful Critique

Questions

​Where are you in your process?

What can I help you with the most?

Can you tell me more about what your objectives are?



What did using this tool (writing, slideshow, other) help you accomplish? or, What did you learn  from using this tool?

How long did it take you to make this?

Do you feel like it was worth the time and effort? Why or why not?

What were your considerations as you created this?

​How did you decide what the main problem is?


​
Did you feel that (writing, slideshow, other) was the right tool for the task? Why?

What are some patterns you found in your (preliminary research/ testing)?

What if _____

Mindsets

​If the designer’s message does not come through clearly, ask more questions! Don’t assume; that makes an “ass” of “u” and “me”. Ask instead!

The one doing the talking is doing the thinking; get the creator thinking and talking

Critique is not "Let me tell you what I would have done".​
Proudly powered by Weebly
  • Projects
    • Shift
    • Ritual
    • Colors and Shapes
    • Tensegrity
    • Lakeview Cut
    • Second Nature
    • It Gets Funkier
    • Making Space
    • Rotational Volumes
    • Changed By Chairs
    • Gearboxes
    • Pendulums
    • Microscopic Images
    • Inspraytion
    • 60 Word Short Stories
    • PBL Illustrations
    • Foundations Podcast
    • Inclusive Strategies Podcast
  • Helpful Links
    • Critique Questions
    • Lasercutting
    • Drawing Models
    • Honors
  • Blog
  • About